Sunday, September 21, 2008

Get used to choices.

I have often had debating thoughts about whether arranged marriages or love marriages are better options. Our lecture on interpersonal communications gave me a reason to research a little about this issue and come to a conclusion. In the process of researching, I learnt a lot about arranged marriages and the fact that there were different types. For example, in a "forced marriage" the parents choose their son's or daughter's future spouse with no input from their son or daughter. Occasionally, even if the son or daughter disapproves of the choice, the marriage takes place regardless, overriding their objections. In a "child marriage" children, or even infants, are married. The married children often live apart with their respective families until well after puberty. Child marriages are typically made for economic or political reasons. Interesting?
I had a chat with my uncle and my grandfather a few weeks back, about marriage. My grandfather expressed his concerns about his grand children (my cousins and myself) getting married to partners of other cultures or races. Naturally, belonging to a younger generation, my uncle and I failed to understand his concern. I sat on the sofa and watched both of them exchange opposing views about this topic. My uncle felt the need for him to move on with times and to learn to except changes in society, while my grandfather felt the need to stick to traditions. His reasons for believing that arranged marriages were a better option included the following.
(1) Youngsters these days are too easily influenced by the effects of love to make logical choices.
In arranged marriages, many factors are considered in choosing the right partner. Some factors include
· Reputation of the family
· Religion
· Wealth and stability
· Horoscope
· Health (any pre-existing health problems?)
· Physical appearance (Boy should be taller than the girl, girl should be fair)
We see over here, how physical appearance plays a relatively important role in relational formation and development, and how judgments of physical attractiveness are influenced by cultural norms, especially in the early stages of relationships.
This ensures that potential problems that can arise in a marriage are already looked into. “This is why most arranged marriages are successful” He said.
My uncle however, felt that some were superficial factors that were considered in finding the right partner. He conformed to the idea of marrying someone you genuinely love and can get along with, provided he or she comes from a good family and that two can support each other and the family well enough.
(2) Couples and their parents may have more similar cultural and social backgrounds rather than that of their host country's culture.
He mentioned that inter-caste marriages weaken the caste system, which is generally not preferred. Noticing how unconvinced I was, he went on to explain to me that marriage does not only involve the union of two people, but also the union of two families. When backgrounds are similar, good interaction falls into place automatically. When two families have different values and practices, very often adapting to them becomes challenging. Take for example a family who practices vegetarianism and a family who doesn’t. Can you imagine having to give up meat for life in order to adapt to your new family?
This exchange continued till the two of them sipped their last bit of tea. I came across an interesting video online that captured the shift in perception about an ideal marriage, between two different generations. Have a look at it.
http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=arranged+marriage&search_type=&aq=0&oq=arranged
We see how the parents of the girl adhere to the traditional practice of arranged marriages or match-making. The video displays a typical “first meeting” between the girl and her husband-to-be. The families have done their background research about each other and are satisfied. Clearly, she does not know anything about him, other than his name. (Raju). We see how she centres herself between her parents, directly opposite the boy. However, the video then moves on to her grabbing a remote control and “choosing” the “channel” of her choice. This is a good representation of how the concept of arrange marriages are being adopted and altered. For instance, another point my grandfather raised when my uncle encouraged him to move on with times was that now, elders find a list of potential partners for their child to choose from. This means that the two are introduced to each other and they have the honour of deciding whether or not they would like to take this meeting to another level. The video then goes on to her finding her “Mr Right Guy”. My favourite part of the clip however, is the part where the girl’s mother grabs the remote and points to her husband. The video ends with the caption “Get used to choices”. This is particularly significant because it reinforces the idea of having to move on with times and adapt to the shifts in mentality.

I still haven’t made up my mind as to which I feel is better.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

it is interesting to note that, according to Time magazine I believe, arranged marriages, or non-love marriages actually have a lower rate of divorce globally. Arranged marriages can lead to love as well, because love is just accepting and adapting to another person so well that you each become the perfect fit for the other. Love is specifically designed to overwhelm logic and sometimes that outside factor like your parents can stop you from doing the wrong thing. My opinion at any rate :D

JANICECHIAN said...

i think that love without marriage is torture. Well, unless there is already some form of attraction there. Whereby even after arranged marriages the courtship could happen and some love story happens for there.

I am however very pro-love-marriage. Well, but thats possibly because i'm someone who thinks love makes the world go round and all that jazz. On the other hand, marriage can really be the funeral of love.

So i suppose, it depends on each couple. How they view things in life and how they take things too. Love-marriages work for some, arranged-marriages work for the rest.

kAi LiN said...

Personally i am against arranged marriages. In arranged marriage, it is assumed that people with matching looks and comparable education level would be happy together.. however these 2 parties have never come together to date and they do not know if they are able to communicate with each other.. i still think romance should precede a marriage..since there is more communication right from the start, there is less risk involved.. although it seemed that there is less divorce cases for arranged marriages (or is it, that is just my assumption). Since arranged marriages is very much more prevalent in the previous 2 generations, the mindset then is more conservative and most will stay in marriage no matter what.